When Me Hates Me

Why do they hate us?

 

I am trying to wrap my mind around the complex and bizarre xenophobic attacks in South Africa perpetrated by a small, but scary section of the population .  The why, the why, the why … it just doesn’t add up.

 

I know we Africans are as different as the languages we speak and the cultures we represent, but I assumed that we were united by the brotherhood of a continent in upheaval and the spirit of ubuntu.

 

Now, I just don’t know.

 

When I first visited Johannesburg in 1999 as a young reporter covering the All Africa Games, the general dislike of Africans from outside South Africa was evident in some sections of the society.  I was told by several black South Africans about how Nigerians were the cause of the rising drug abuse in the country, how gangs of Zimbabweans – even before the economic crisis there – were behind gun crime, how Mozambicans were pests. However I did not witness any blatant acts of xenophobia. 

 

Or maybe I did.  Maybe the seeds of the past 10 days of violence were sown more than a decade ago.

 

I don’t know.

 

I don’t understand the link many people are making regarding social injustice in South African townships and xenophobia.

 

A blogger from the Foreign Policy Institute blames the xenophobia on “growing food insecurity in the nation, a broken system for handling refugees and total failure of Mbeki’s government to seek political solutions to the crisis in Zimbabwe.”  Justin Hartman concurs in his post titled “State of the Nation: Fucked.”  He says the xenophobic attacks are a culmination of years of suppressed anger and frustration towards Government’s lack of providing and delivery of promises made.

 

Michael T, writing on the Political Blog, says “once again, just as the recent electricity supply fiasco this government has failed to heed the warnings so clearly seen in the townships and on the streets on South Africa, where millions of people have been robbed of a future they were promised. This is only the beginning; the worst is yet to come.”

 

I still don’t get it.  Your government fails you, so instead of turning against your government, you turn against the poor foreigners in your midst?  I suppose it happens in varying degrees around the world, but still somebody help me because I just don’t know.
A number of South African bloggers – most who seem as confused about the xenophobia as I am – are calling on their government to take charge of a situation that has been allowed to spiral out of control.  Afrigator has dedicated a page to reporting on xenophobia and calls for reconciliation (click on the picture below to go to the page).

 

Stii is of the opinion that only through spreading the word about xenophobia can people be alerted to the horrors of this new injustice.  Mike calls on the white South Africans not to turn an eye to a situation that may not directly affect them, but to use their social and political positions to call for an end to the violence.
Om writes,

I don’t care the fact that the violence directed at fellow African migrants is by a tiny group of South Africans, it nonetheless highlights the unwillingness of the larger population to stand up and defend their values by being silent for so damn long.

 

Angry African is ashamed.  “Ashamed of being a South African. Ashamed of the behavior of my countrymen. Ashamed of South Africans. Ashamed of South Africa. And every South African should be. Be ashamed.”

 

Outside the blogosphere, other South Africans seem equally horrified by the xenophobia.  DJ Sbu of YFM this week led a demonstration through the East Rand calling for people not to turn against ‘their brothers’.

The Times is running a special report on the xenophobia called Flames of Hate and it is available hereMail and Guardian Online also have a dedicated xenophobia page here.

 

 

As for me, highlighting the work of others is all I can do because … I just don’t know.

About these ads

11 Comments to “When Me Hates Me”

  1. It’s easy to think the marauding bands show what all of South Africa feels, but they just may be the minority. When there was some little anti-Indian pogrom here, 99.9% of Uganda was shocked and angered. Even though, of course, everybody was saying Ugandans were beating up Indians.

    I think there are some few with frustrations about these other people coming in, getting lots of dough, and not being of the land. I think, when non-South Africans go down there, they stand a better chance at succeeding than the other Black SA people, which broods resentment. (Foreigners are more-educated, and without the crippling effects of AIDS and crime and so on, which are themselves the crippling effects of Apartheid, which the foreigners didn’t suffer.) And if you can’t attack the White foreigners, you can still access your brothers. Sibling rivalry, I would say. :-|

    Not to forget the politicians who, I’ve read, have taken the issue to get political capital out of it. Opposition ones, as always. So, successful, accessible foreigners, many resentful people, a few disgruntled, impressionable, unemployed, hammer-wielding youths, and a pinch of politician. Bring to simmer, and add history. Serve your ready xenophobic pogrom. :-( Where have I seen this before …

  2. What I don’t get is the silence of the political elite. They haven’t done enough, and yet they – more than anybody else in that country – were the beneficiaries of African hospitality and “brotherhood” when they went into exile.

    The “Frontline States” risked the apartheid government’s bombings and blockades in order to play host to exiled ANC, PAC, etc leadership, (some even hosted training camps, set up schools, paid for medical care) and now these same characters can’t stand up and denounce the violence?

    Pisses me off.

  3. the biggest question is why? its like south africans are a different brand of africans and don’t want to be a part of us…

  4. The capacity for humans to be evil has always astounded me. I totally echo Jasmine in saying *sigh*

  5. Cosign Darlkom. It seems like it’s the sort of thing people just do.

    I am convinced it’s going to happen here, too. And the definition of “foreigner” hasn’t yet been decided, so any of us could be in shit.

  6. Man. I don’t know what to think. All I can say is that these people don’t reflect what the majority of South Africans are about. We are proud of being African and being part of Africa. And we know what our African brothers and sisters have done to help us in the past. And by African I mean all of those who live in Africa and feel it in their blood and in their bones. No race or religion excluded.

    To all of you I ask just one thing. Please don’t judge us on what this band of murderers are doing. As we don’t judge others on the small band of criminals doing it their either. We are all better than this. All of us – inside and outside South Africa.

  7. Cosigning Dee,and Baz tooo

    Sy, you do know that they do feel that way about numerous things…

    Almost all their ish is carefully branded “proudly South African”

  8. Ditto to AngryAfrican.

    I am ashamed to be South African at the moment.

  9. No Comrade, it’s not only 1% of South Africans that feel like that. A much larger group does. I lived there for three and a half years and you’d sit in a taxi and get a lady yelling at you for being in her country and not being to speak her language. There is a definite case of xenophobia in SA. We even did a whole study on it in South African politics. It’s a major problem. But, like AngryAfrican and Sarah, not everyone is like this. All my SA friends were actually South African. I went to their homes and slept there, ate with them, had weddings and funerals with them. They didn’t shun my being a foreigner. There’s a lot more to this than we can understand. SA needs healing from above.

  10. @the 27th comrade Little did you know that a year later the would be xenophocic attacks in your country and that they would claim more lives, you see its comments like yours that wil create a futher rift. We are not the AIDS capital of the world, mater of fact our infection rate is slowly going down, our hiv aids program is among the best in the world. you are overating yourselves with this education delusion of granduer because if you were half of what you say you are, your country wouldnt be as appaling as it is now.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,441 other followers

%d bloggers like this: